Projection Bias
Assuming others share your beliefs and values
What is it?
Projection bias covers two related phenomena: assuming other people share our preferences, beliefs and values (social projection), and assuming our future selves will have the same preferences as our current selves (intertemporal projection). Both stem from the difficulty of imagining perspectives different from our current one. Social projection leads product developers to build what they want rather than what customers need, negotiators to misjudge counterparts' priorities, and managers to assume employees are motivated by the same things they are. Intertemporal projection leads us to overestimate how much we'll enjoy future purchases based on current desires (shopping hungry tends to mean buying too much food), to underestimate how our preferences will change (career choices made at 20 may not fit at 40), and to make commitments our future selves will regret. Studies of "hot" and "cold" states suggest we struggle to imagine states different from our current one: when full, it is hard to imagine being hungry. In organizations, projection bias contributes to failed products, ineffective incentives and communication breakdowns. Counteracting it requires actively seeking input from diverse perspectives, conducting actual user research rather than imagining user needs, and building in flexibility for changing preferences.
Example
Designing a product based on what you want, not customer research. Shopping hungry and buying too much food. Assuming employees are motivated by what motivates you.
Try it
Ross, Greene and House (1977) gave this story, in dollars and miles per hour, to 80 Stanford students. Before saying what they would do, each estimated what share of their peers would pay and what share would go to court; here, you chose first and estimated after. Then 46% said they would pay, and 54% that they would contest. Those who chose to pay had estimated, on average, that 71.8% would pay and 28.2% contest; those who chose to contest, that 51.7% would pay and 48.3% contest. Each group rated its own choice as more common than the other group did: the authors called this the false consensus effect.
Ross, L., Greene, D., & House, P. (1977). The “false consensus effect”: An egocentric bias in social perception and attribution processes. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 13(3), 279-301.
References
Loewenstein, G., O'Donoghue, T., & Rabin, M. (2003). Projection Bias in Predicting Future Utility. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 118(4), 1209-1248.
Van Boven, L., & Loewenstein, G. (2003). Social Projection of Transient Drive States. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 29(9), 1159-1168.
How to Prevent It
Doxa uses AI and can make mistakes. How it's built
Do others actually share my preferences?
Have I actually asked people what they want?
Will I still want this in a year, once today's mood or situation has passed?
What might someone with different values prefer?
How different is my target audience from myself?
Conduct surveys or interviews to validate assumptions.
Test ideas with diverse groups before committing.
Create user personas based on research, not assumptions.
Observe actual behavior rather than relying on intuition.
Include team members with different backgrounds in decisions.
Related Decisions
Relocating to a new city
May project current needs onto future self
Committing to a relationship
May assume partner shares your values
Setting pricing strategy
May assume customers value same things you do
Making family planning decisions
May assume partner shares your timeline and expectations
Making a major life decision
May assume others, or your future self, want what you want now
Choosing a co-founder
May assume they share your goals, pace and appetite for risk
Caring for an aging parent
May assume your parent wants what you would want
Adopting a pet
May assume your schedule and home will stay as they are now